Carnival Row: An act of inspiration or creative theft?

Featured1

Carnival Row is a 2019 neo-Noir fantasy series released through Amazon. The plot centers on a pair of star-crossed lovers, one winged and one not, who met during a war. Does this sound familiar?

Saga, the best-selling comic from Image, follows the story of Alana and Marko, a pair of star-crossed lovers, one winged and one horned, who fought on opposite sides of a war. And Saga debuted in 2012.

Carnival Row has allegedly been in development for nearly 18 years. Even if this is true, a project can be in development for a long time and still draw inspiration from additional sources at a later stage of development. Having worked on developing local animation and pilots, I’m aware of how much a show changes from original concept to final product and how much pressure can be brought to bear on a creative team to make a show align more closely to popular intellectual properties.

There is a worrying trend where big budget shows lift character designs, central story-lines and often, large amounts of dialogue from comics,  web-comics and little-known manga without much regard for the original creators, copyright or creative integrity. Based on the trailers, marketing and elements of the aesthetic, Carnival Row appears to draw inspiration from the world of Saga. I’ll be curious to see if additional elements of Carnival Row (those not found in Saga) have been “borrowed” from other comics and sources instead.

Certain story-lines and archetypes are staples in the fantasy genre. For example, both George R. R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire and Robin Hobb’s Farseer series involve a bastard, his wolf, dragons and political intrigue. But the characters, themes and story-lines are very different. Whereas there are some undeniable similarities between Saga and Carnival Row.

Faun

The aesthetic of Carnival Row‘s central fantasy races appears to draw freely from Saga as do several key scenes in the Carnival Row trailers. Some of Saga‘s significant plot points (such as the lovers bonding over a novel) are also included in Carnival Row. However, this is a fairly common plot device in fictional romances. Unlike Saga, Carnival Row boasts a steam-punk Victorian setting as opposed to a space opera one and a vastly different central narrative.

It remains to be seen whether the show simply contains some nods to Saga as a source of visual inspiration or is guilty of creative theft.

2 comments

    • I thought that the article made it clear that it was a response to the marketing and trailers for the show, not the show itself. Especially the tone and concluding lines of the piece, which give the Carnival Row the benefit of the doubt. But to clarify things, I have added some additional text.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s